Chapter 9

Jonathan was charged with kidnapping, assault, attempted murder, child endangerment, and a dozen other crimes.
The judge denied bail.
He was locked up in the maximum-security wing of the county jail, awaiting trial.
His lawyer quit two days later, saying he couldn’t represent a man who’d "knowingly put an infant’s life at risk."
Jonathan was appointed a public defender, who told him he was looking at thirty years to life if he was convicted.
For a while, things were calm.
Clara was okay—scared, clingy, waking up screaming in the night for a week, but physically unhurt.
Maggie stayed with us for a month, helping me take care of her, sleeping in the nursery with a baseball bat under her bed, just in case.
Nathaniel doubled the security at the estate, put new gates, new cameras, new alarms on every window and door.
We tried to go back to normal.
But normal was gone.
I couldn’t leave Clara alone for a second.
If she was napping, I sat outside her door, watching her breathe.
If we went for a walk, I held her so tight my arms ached.
I had nightmares every night—Jonathan taking her again, dropping her from the mill railing, hurting her while I watched, helpless.
I jumped at every loud noise, every car that drove down the long driveway, every knock on the door.
Nathaniel tried to help.
He made me go to therapy, twice a week.
He sat with me through the bad dreams, held me while I cried, told me over and over that Jonathan was gone, that we were safe.
But the fear didn’t go away.
It was always there, a cold knot in my stomach, waiting for the other shoe to drop.
And drop it did.
It was a Tuesday, three months after the kidnapping.
Clara was ten months old, crawling everywhere, pulling herself up on the furniture, saying "Mama" and "Papa" (she’d started calling Nathaniel Papa a month earlier, and he’d cried for an hour).
We were in the living room, playing on the floor with her blocks, when the mail came.
Nathaniel opened the stack of letters, his face going pale as he pulled out a plain white envelope with no return address.
"What is it?" I asked, sitting up.
He didn’t answer.
He just opened the envelope, pulling out a single piece of paper and a small photo.
He handed them to me.
The photo was of me and Clara, taken through the kitchen window that morning.
We were making pancakes.
Clara was sitting in her high chair, covered in syrup, laughing.
I was standing beside her, wiping her face, smiling.
It had been taken that day.
While we were inside.
While security was patrolling the grounds.
The note was typed, no signature.
You think a few walls and cameras are enough to keep her safe?
You think a jail cell can hold me forever?
I have friends on the outside, Grace.
Friends who owe me favors.
Friends who will watch you.
Wait for you.
And when the time is right...
We’ll take her again.
And next time, you’ll never find her.
I dropped the photo and the note like they were on fire.
My hands were shaking.
My breath came in short, fast gasps.
I couldn’t breathe.
I couldn’t think.
Nathaniel grabbed me, holding me upright, slapping my face gently.
"Breathe, Grace. Come on. In and out. You’re okay. Clara’s okay. We’re okay."
He yelled for the head of security, Marco, who ran in, his hand on his gun.
Nathaniel showed him the note and the photo.
Marco’s face went hard.
"I’ll get the team on it, sir. We’ll check every camera, every foot of the fence line, every car that’s been on the property in the last week. Whoever took this, we’ll find them. And no one is getting through the gates again. I promise."
He ran out.
Nathaniel turned back to me, his face tight with worry.
"I want you and Clara to pack a bag," he said.
"We’re leaving tonight. Going to the house in Aspen. It’s a gated community, private security, no one gets in without three forms of ID. We’ll stay there until we find out who sent this. Until we know you’re safe."
I nodded, picking Clara up off the floor, holding her tight.
She snuggled into my neck, completely unaware of how close we’d come to losing everything again.
That night, we flew to Aspen on Nathaniel’s private jet.
The house was huge, made of stone and wood, tucked into the side of a mountain, surrounded by pine trees and fresh snow.
It was beautiful.
But I couldn’t enjoy it.
Every time I looked out the window, I expected to see someone watching me.
Every time the wind blew, I grabbed Clara and ran to the middle of the room.
Two days later, Nathaniel got a call from Marco.
He’d found the man who’d taken the photo—a homeless guy who’d been paid five hundred dollars by a stranger to sneak onto the property and take the picture.
He didn’t know who the stranger was.
Just that he was tall, wore a hoodie, had a scar on his left cheek.
He’d given the guy the camera and told him to leave the film at a drop box in town.
No name.
No phone number.
Nothing.
The note was a dead end too.
Typed on a public library computer, no fingerprints, no DNA.
Whoever was doing this was good.
Too good.
That night, I couldn’t sleep.
I got up, walking out to the big deck overlooking the mountains.
The air was cold, crisp, smelling of pine and snow.
The stars were so bright they looked like diamonds scattered across the sky.
Nathaniel came out a few minutes later, wrapping a blanket around my shoulders.
"You should be inside," he said.
"It’s freezing."
"I can’t sleep," I said, staring out at the dark.
"What if they find us here, Nathaniel? What if they follow us? What if they take her again? I can’t go through that again. I’d rather die than go through that again."
He pulled me against his chest, his chin resting on the top of my head.
"No one is gonna take her," he said.
"I won’t let them. I’ve got security all over this mountain. The house is a fortress. And even if they did get through—they’d have to go through me first. And I will die before I let anyone hurt either of you."
He paused, then said, soft, like he was scared to say the words out loud.
"I love you, Grace. You know that, right? You and Clara are the best things that ever happened to me. I spent twenty years alone, thinking I’d never have a family. And then you walked into my life, and everything made sense. I’m not gonna let anyone take that away from us. Not Jonathan. Not his friends. No one."
I looked up at him, tears in my eyes.
No one had ever said that to me.
Not my mom, not Maggie, not anyone.
*I love you.*
Simple words.
But they meant everything.
"I love you too, Dad," I said.
It was the first time I’d called him that out loud.
Not Papa, like Clara.
Dad.
He cried then, quiet tears, holding me tighter.
We stood there for a long time, watching the stars, holding each other, drawing strength from each other.
Then Nathaniel’s phone rang.
He answered, his face going hard.
He listened for a minute, then hung up, looking at me.
"That was the warden at the jail," he said.
"Jonathan was attacked last night. In the shower. Stabbed three times. He’s in the hospital. Critical condition. They don’t think he’s gonna make it."
I stared at him, my mouth dry.
Jonathan was dying.
The man who’d ruined my life, who’d taken my baby, who’d threatened to kill us all... was dying.
And for the first time in a long time...
I didn’t feel relief.
I felt fear.
Because if Jonathan was dying...
Who was sending the notes?
May you like
Who was watching us?
And what did they want?