Chapter 5

The first week in the apartment was the hardest.
I cried myself to sleep every night.
I checked my phone every five minutes, hoping for a text from Daniel.
Something.
Anything.
But the only messages were from the bank—automatic payments going through.
The only calls were from telemarketers.
Daniel had gone completely silent.
On the eighth day, I woke up and decided I was done crying.
I got out of bed, made coffee, and sat down at the kitchen table with a notepad.
I wrote Evelyn's name at the top.
And beneath it, I listed every single thing she'd done to me since I'd married Daniel.
The ruined speech.
The missing jewelry that had mysteriously turned up in my suitcase before a business trip.
The time my car brakes had "failed" the morning of an important job interview.
The anonymous letters sent to my parents, filled with lies about my "wild past."
The pool.
The journal.
The scratches on her own face.
I had twenty-seven items on my list by the time I finished.
Twenty-seven separate incidents.
And I'd bet my life there were more I didn't know about.
I needed proof.
Real proof.
Not a journal she could claim I'd forged.
Something irrefutable.
That afternoon, I went to the electronics store.
I bought the smallest, highest-quality voice recorder they had.
I bought three of them.
And I bought a tiny, motion-activated camera with night vision.
I knew Evelyn would come for me.
She wouldn't be satisfied with just exiling me to the apartment.
She'd want me gone completely.
Divorced.
Disgraced.
Ideally, in her perfect world, dead.
And she'd want to gloat.
People like her always wanted to gloat.
I set up the camera above the front door, angled so it would capture anyone who entered.
I placed the voice recorders in the living room, the kitchen, and the bedroom.
Then I waited.
I didn't have to wait long.
Three days later, my doorbell rang at two in the afternoon.
I checked the camera feed on my phone.
It was her.
Evelyn.
Dressed in a cream tailored suit, wearing oversized sunglasses, carrying a small leather handbag.
I smiled to myself.
Showtime.
I pressed record on all three voice recorders through my phone.
Then I opened the door.
"Evelyn," I said, keeping my face neutral. "To what do I owe this pleasure?"
She smiled and removed her sunglasses, her eyes scanning my apartment with obvious distaste.
"May I come in, dear? We have much to discuss."
I stepped aside.
She swept past me, her perfume filling the small space.
She sat on the sofa, crossing her legs, placing her handbag precisely on the cushion beside her.
"You've made this so much more difficult than it needed to be," she said, sighing as if she genuinely regretted it.
"Have I?" I asked, sitting across from her in the armchair.
"Mmm," she said, nodding. "Daniel is... fragile right now. He loves you, in his own way. But he loves his family more. He loves his name more. And he'll never choose you over the Carter legacy. Never."
I said nothing.
I just let her talk.
People like her always filled the silence.
"I came here to make you an offer," she said, leaning forward slightly. "A generous one. Sign the divorce papers. Admit that you attacked me. Issue a public apology to the family. And in return, I'll make sure you get two million dollars. Tax-free. In an account in the Caymans. No one will ever know you were a Carter. You can go back to wherever you came from and live like a queen."
Two million dollars.
She thought I could be bought.
She thought two million dollars was enough to make me forget being drowned, lied about, hunted.
"And if I say no?" I asked.
Her smile didn't waver.
But her eyes went cold.
"Then things get very ugly for you, Emily. Very ugly indeed."
She reached into her handbag and pulled out a manila folder.
She tossed it onto the coffee table between us.
"Daniel's grandmother's diamond necklace," she said calmly. "Worth four hundred thousand dollars. Reported stolen from the family safe three days ago. The police will be here within the hour. And look—what's this?"
She reached into the side of my sofa—the side I never used—and pulled out a small velvet jewelry box.
She opened it.
The necklace was inside.
Sparkling.
Damning.
"I planted it this morning, while you were out buying groceries," she said, her voice almost cheerful. "The building security camera caught you entering the main house yesterday. You were there to 'get your winter clothes,' remember? That's what you told the gate guard. Plenty of opportunity to break into the safe."
I stared at her.
She'd thought of everything.
The security footage.
The timing.
The necklace itself.
If the police found it here, I'd go to prison.
Grand theft.
Four hundred thousand dollars.
Ten years minimum.
"You're insane," I whispered.
"Am I?" she asked, tilting her head. "Or am I just a woman who protects what's hers? Daniel was never yours to take. The Carter fortune was never yours to spend. I've spent forty years building this family's legacy. I won't let a little nobody from a broken home tear it down."
She stood up, smoothing her skirt.
"You have until four o'clock," she said, checking her watch. "Sign the papers and take the money. Or the police come, and you spend the next decade of your life in a cell. And believe me—with the family's connections, you won't get parole. You'll rot there."
She walked toward the door.
"Think about it, Emily," she said over her shoulder. "Two million dollars. Or ten years. It's not really a choice, is it?"
The door clicked shut behind her.
I sat frozen in the armchair for what felt like hours.
She'd outplayed me again.
The necklace was here.
The security footage existed.
Her story was airtight.
No one would believe me if I said she'd planted it.
She was Evelyn Carter.
Matriarch.
Philanthropist.
Saint.
And I was the gold-digging wife who'd already attacked her once.
I looked at the jewelry box on the coffee table.
Four hundred thousand dollars' worth of diamonds.
My entire future resting on a few tiny pieces of carbon.
Then I remembered the camera.
The recorders.
I grabbed my phone and pulled up the footage.
There she was.
Entering my apartment.
Sitting on the sofa.
Making the offer.
Pulling the necklace from my couch.
Admitting she'd planted it.
Admitting everything.
I downloaded the file to three separate cloud drives.
I emailed it to myself at three different addresses.
I saved it to a USB drive and put it in my safe.
Then I called Daniel.
He answered on the seventh ring.
"Emily?" he said, his voice guarded. "I don't think we should—"
"She's here," I said, cutting him off. "Or she was. She just left. She planted her mother's diamond necklace in my sofa. She's going to call the police at four o'clock and have me arrested for grand theft unless I sign divorce papers and admit I attacked her."
There was a long silence on the other end.
"Emily, that's—"
"She admitted it, Daniel," I said, my voice shaking with urgency. "She said she planted it this morning while I was grocery shopping. She offered me two million dollars to disappear. She said she'd spent forty years building the family legacy and she wouldn't let me tear it down. I have it all on camera. Every word. Every move. She even pulled the necklace out of the couch on film."
Another silence.
Longer this time.
"Where are you?" he asked finally.
His voice was different now.
Alert.
Scared.
"In the apartment," I said. "She said the police come at four. Daniel, it's almost three-thirty. I need you. Please."
"I'm on my way," he said, and the line went dead.
I sat back in the armchair, staring at the necklace.
May you like
I'd played right into Evelyn's trap.
But this time—for the first time—I'd brought a net.