Chapter 4

Daniel rushed past me to his mother's side.
He didn't even glance at me.
Not once.
He knelt on the floor, gathering Evelyn into his arms, his face ashen.
"Mom! Oh my God, what happened?"
She sobbed against his shoulder, her whole body shaking, her hand pressed to the scratches on her face.
"She... she attacked me," she gasped, pointing a shaking finger in my direction. "I came in to apologize, to bring her a peace offering, and she just... she flew at me. She said if I didn't leave the family forever, she'd make sure I regretted it."
Daniel looked up at me then.
And the expression on his face will haunt me for the rest of my life.
It wasn't confusion anymore.
It was horror.
Disappointment.
Betrayal.
"Emily?" he said, his voice barely recognizable. "Is that true?"
I stood frozen on the stairs, the journal still clutched in my white-knuckled grip.
"No," I said, stepping down toward them. "Daniel, look at this. I found it in her room. It's her journal. She planned everything—the pool, the gala, all of it. She scratched herself. She's acting."
Evelyn let out a fresh wail, burying her face deeper into Daniel's chest.
"She's been going through my things," she wept. "She said she'd find something to use against me. She said she'd destroy this family if it was the last thing she did."
Daniel looked at the journal in my hands.
I held it out to him, desperate.
"Read it," I begged. "Just read it. Please."
He hesitated, his eyes darting between his mother's tear-streaked face and the leather book in my hand.
For one heartbeat, I thought he would take it.
I thought he would read it and understand and everything would be okay.
Then Evelyn tightened her grip on him, whimpering softly.
And he wrapped his arms more firmly around her.
"Not now," he said, his voice cold. "Not like this. You've done enough, Emily."
I felt as if he'd physically struck me.
"I've done enough?" I repeated, disbelieving. "Daniel, she tried to drown me. She wrote about it. She planned it. And you're holding her like she's the victim?"
"Go upstairs," he said, standing up with his mother in his arms. "Now. We'll talk about this when everyone is calm."
"I'm not going anywhere until you read that journal," I said, planting my feet. "She's manipulating you. Can't you see that? She's been manipulating you your whole life!"
His face darkened.
"That's enough," he said, his voice like steel. "I won't have you speak about my mother that way. Not in my house. Not ever."
He carried Evelyn toward the guest wing, and I stood there in the empty hallway, the journal burning a hole in my hands.
He didn't come to our bedroom that night.
I sat on the edge of the bed until three in the morning, waiting.
The journal lay open on the nightstand, the damning entry about the pool glowing in the lamplight.
I read it over and over, trying to understand how Daniel could look at the woman who'd written those words and see only a loving mother.
At four o'clock, I heard the front door open and close.
I looked out the window and saw Evelyn getting into a car with a suitcase.
She was leaving.
But not because she'd been caught.
Because she'd won.
The next morning, the calls started coming.
First from Daniel's aunt Margaret.
Then from his cousin Robert.
Then from his godmother, who I'd always thought liked me.
Each call was the same.
Disappointment.
Judgment.
How could I attack a poor, grieving widow?
How could I be so jealous of a mother's love for her son?
Had I ever really loved Daniel, or had I just been after the Carter money all along?
By noon, the entire family knew.
And they all believed Evelyn.
Every single one of them.
Daniel came home at dinnertime, looking exhausted.
He didn't kiss me hello.
He didn't even make eye contact.
He poured himself a whiskey and stood by the fireplace, swirling the amber liquid in the glass.
"The family is very upset," he said, not looking at me.
"I can imagine," I said, my voice tight. "She called them all, didn't she? Before she even left the house."
"She was scared, Emily," he said, finally turning to face me. "You left her with scratches on her face. What was she supposed to do?"
"She did that to herself!" I shouted, slamming my hand on the table. "Why won't you believe me? I have proof! Right here!" I grabbed the journal and waved it at him. "Read it! Just read one page! If you read it and still think I'm lying, I'll... I'll leave. I'll go away and never bother either of you again."
Daniel flinched as if I'd threatened him.
He set down his whiskey glass slowly, his movements deliberate.
"I don't want to read it," he said quietly.
I stared at him, uncomprehending.
"What?"
"I said I don't want to read it," he repeated, his voice harder now. "Because I know what I'll find. I know you, Emily. I know how desperate you've been to turn me against my mother. You'd write anything. Forge anything. Just to win."
The room spun.
"You think I forged it?" I whispered.
"I think you're capable of a lot right now," he said, his eyes glistening. "The woman I married would never attack a defenseless old woman. The woman I married would never sneak through private journals and lie and manipulate. I don't know who you are anymore."
He turned away from me, his shoulders shaking slightly.
"I've arranged for you to stay at the city apartment for a while," he said, his voice breaking. "Just until things calm down. Until we can both think clearly."
He still hadn't read the journal.
He wouldn't even touch it.
The one piece of evidence that could prove everything, and he was refusing to look at it.
I packed my bag in silence.
I left the journal on the bed between us—open to the entry about the pool.
He didn't glance at it once.
He drove me to the apartment in silence.
He carried my bag to the door.
And then he just stood there, looking at me with those sad, confused eyes.
"I still love you," he said softly. "Whatever this is... whatever's happening to us... I still love you."
I wanted to believe him.
I wanted to throw myself into his arms and make it all go away.
But I'd seen what happened when love was stronger than the truth.
"Then read the journal, Daniel," I said, my voice steady despite the tears running down my face. "If you love me even a fraction of how much you love her... read it."
I closed the door before he could answer.
I stood in the empty apartment, listening to his car pull away.
I was alone.
Completely, utterly alone.
The whole Carter family was against me.
My own husband didn't believe me.
And Evelyn was out there, free and clear, probably already planning her next move.
But as I looked around the small, unfamiliar apartment, something shifted inside me.
The fear that had been my constant companion for three years was gone.
In its place was something harder.
Colder.
Stronger.
Evelyn wanted a war.
May you like
Fine.
She'd got one.