Chapter 5

I didn’t sleep at all that night.
I lay in the guest room—our bedroom felt too much like a crime scene—and stared at the ceiling.
Every sound the house made felt like someone breaking in.
Every shadow in the corner felt like a man with a gun.
By five in the morning, I had given up on sleep entirely.
I made coffee.
Strong.
Black.
And I sat at the kitchen table, going through everything I knew.
Daniel was desperate.
Desperate men were dangerous men.
He owed seven hundred and fifty thousand dollars to people who didn’t mess around.
He had tried to steal twelve million from me and failed.
Now he had nothing.
No money.
No escape plan.
A pregnant mistress who hated him.
And the police, the FBI, and half the state of Tennessee about to start looking for him.
A man with nothing left to lose was the most dangerous kind of man there was.
At six o’clock, my father came downstairs.
He was already dressed.
“I’m going to the bank now,” he said. “They open at seven for priority clients. I’ll have the money by eight-thirty.”
“Be careful,” I said.
“Always am.”
He kissed my forehead and left.
My mother was still asleep.
I poured another cup of coffee and opened my laptop.
Maya had sent a file overnight.
Everything she had on Daniel.
All of it.
I started reading.
And the more I read, the angrier I got.
The gambling went back further than he had admitted.
Four years.
Not two.
Total losses: almost nine hundred thousand dollars.
All paid from joint accounts I thought were for household expenses.
He had been siphoning money from me for years.
Fifty dollars here.
Two hundred there.
Then bigger amounts.
Thousands.
Tens of thousands.
And I hadn’t noticed.
Because I trusted him.
Because I thought love meant not checking up on someone.
Maya had also found the apartment he had rented for Lauren.
A two-bedroom place in a nice part of town.
$3,200 a month.
Paid from my account.
For fourteen months.
There were photos.
Hundreds of them.
Daniel and Lauren at restaurants.
At the movies.
At the grocery store.
Holding hands.
Kissing.
Living their life together while I was at home, waiting for him to come back from “late meetings.”
There were photos of the courthouse too.
Daniel and Lauren emerging as husband and wife.
He was smiling.
She was holding a bouquet of daisies.
My favorite flower.
He had bought her my favorite flower on their wedding day.
I closed the laptop.
I couldn’t read any more.
At eight forty-five, my father returned.
He carried a black canvas duffel bag.
He dropped it on the kitchen table with a heavy thud.
“Seven hundred and fifty thousand,” he said. “In hundreds. It weighs about eighteen pounds. You could kill someone with this bag.”
“Good to know,” I said.
I unzipped it.
Stacks of money.
Band after band.
Green rectangles.
More money than most people would see in a lifetime.
And to me, it had just become bait.
“Now what?” my father asked.
“Now we wait for Daniel to call,” I said. “He will. Before noon. He has nowhere else to go.”
My phone rang at 11:02 AM.
Blocked number.
I answered.
“Hello.”
“Sarah.” Daniel’s voice. Rough. Tired. Scared. “We need to talk.”
“I thought we talked last night.”
“I’m serious,” he said. “They’re going to kill me, Sarah. I know you hate me. I know you have every reason to want me dead. But please. Just listen to what I have to say.”
“I’m listening.”
“Meet me,” he said. “At the warehouse on Riverfront Drive. Number 417. Alone. Bring the money.”
“I’m not giving you any money, Daniel.”
“Not for me,” he said quickly. “For them. If I don’t have it in two hours, they’re going to hurt Lauren. Then they’re going to come after you. And your parents. They know where you live, Sarah. They know everything about you. I told them. I had to. They would have killed me otherwise.”
My blood ran cold.
He had given them my name.
My address.
Everything.
“You brought them to my house?”
“I had no choice!” he shouted. “Do you understand what these people are capable of? Last month, a guy owed them fifty grand. They broke both his legs and left him in a dumpster. Fifty thousand. I owe them fifteen times that. They’ll burn your house to the ground with everyone inside. Don’t think they won’t.”
I looked at my father.
He was watching me intently.
I mouthed, He’s bringing them here.
My father nodded.
Picked up his own phone.
Started texting.
“Daniel,” I said into the phone. “I’m not coming to any warehouse alone. That’s ridiculous. You want the money? We do this my way. Public place. Broad daylight. The parking lot of the police station on Third Avenue. One o’clock. You and me. Nobody else. If I see anyone I don’t recognize, I leave. And the money goes to the police as evidence in the fraud case. Do we have a deal?”
Silence on the other end.
I could hear him arguing with someone in the background.
Muffled voices.
Then Daniel came back.
“Okay,” he said. “Police station parking lot. One o’clock. But Sarah—if this is a trap, they won’t hesitate. Not for a second. You think you’re tough because you outsmarted me? You have no idea what you’re dealing with.”
He hung up.
I put the phone down.
My hands were shaking.
“He’s desperate,” I said. “He’s got them with him. They’re going to try something.”
My father stood up.
“Maya is on her way,” he said. “She’s bringing friends. Professional friends. And I called the lead detective on the case. He’s going to have plainclothes officers all over that parking lot. Nobody is touching you.”
“I’m scared, Dad.”
It was the first time I had admitted it out loud.
He sat down next to me and put his arm around my shoulder.
“I know, baby,” he said. “I’d be more worried if you weren’t. But you’re not alone in this. We’re all with you. And we’re going to get through it. Together.”
At twelve-thirty, I got ready.
I put on jeans and a black sweater.
Comfortable shoes.
The duffel bag went into the trunk of my car.
My father drove a separate vehicle.
Maya was already in position when we arrived at the police station.
I saw her instantly, even though she was pretending to read a newspaper on a bench.
She gave me the tiniest nod.
Good.
I parked in the center of the lot.
Most exposed spot.
Most visible from the street.
Most visible from the police station windows.
If they were going to try something, they’d have to do it in front of God and everybody.
At 12:58, Daniel’s car pulled in.
He was alone.
He got out.
Looked terrible.
His shirt was wrinkled.
He had a black eye.
Someone had hit him.
Hard.
He walked toward my car.
I got out.
Left the keys in the ignition.
Left the driver’s door open.
If I needed to run, I wasn’t going to waste time unlocking anything.
“Where is it?” he said without preamble.
“Trunk,” I said. “Where are they, Daniel?”
“Watching,” he said. “From the gray van across the street. Two men. One has a gun. The other has a list of everything you own. They know about the cabin in Montana. The boat on the lake. Your mother’s jewelry. If you don’t hand over the money, they’re going to take it all. And then some.”
I glanced across the street.
Gray van.
Engine running.
Dark windows.
“Open the trunk,” Daniel said. “Give me the bag. And maybe—just maybe—I can talk them into leaving you alone.”
I laughed.
It came out sharper than I intended.
“You still think I’m stupid, don’t you?”
“What?”
“I give you the bag,” I said. “You take it to them. They take the money. And then what? They’ve already seen my face. They know who I am. They know how much I’m worth. Do you really think seven hundred and fifty thousand is going to be enough for them? Once they know how easy it is to get money from me, they’ll be back. Next month. Next week. Tomorrow. You didn’t just borrow money from them, Daniel. You sold them my name. And now they own me. Unless I do something about it.”
His eyes widened.
“What did you do?”
“Me?” I smiled. “I didn’t do anything. Yet.”
Maya stood up from the bench.
Two men in business suits who had been “waiting by the entrance” suddenly moved toward the van.
Three uniformed officers emerged from the police station, walking casually but with purpose.
Daniel saw them.
Realization hit him.
“You set me up,” he whispered. “Again.”
“You brought criminals to my house,” I said. “Threatened my family. What did you expect me to do? Negotiate?”
The gray van’s doors flew open.
Two men jumped out.
They weren’t dressed like stereotypical thugs.
They wore expensive suits.
Looked like accountants.
Or lawyers.
One of them pulled a gun.
“Nobody move!” he shouted.
The parking lot erupted.
People screamed.
Cars started.
The plainclothes officers drew their own weapons.
“DROP THE GUN!”
The man with the gun looked at Daniel.
Looked at me.
Looked at the police surrounding him.
He didn’t drop the gun.
He raised it.
Aimed at me.
Time slowed down.
I saw the finger tighten on the trigger.
Saw Daniel lunge at him.
Not to save me.
To save himself.
If I died, there was no money.
No deal.
No way out.
The gun went off.
BANG.
The bullet went through the sleeve of my sweater.
Missed my arm by an inch.
Shattered the window of the car behind me.
Then the police were on them.
Four officers tackling the man with the gun.
Three more on the second guy from the van.
Daniel was on the ground too.
Handcuffs clicking around his wrists.
“Sarah!” he shouted as they pulled him up. “Tell them I had nothing to do with this! Tell them I tried to stop him!”
I looked at the hole in my sleeve.
The bullet had been so close.
One inch to the left and I’d be in an ambulance right now.
Or worse.
I walked over to him.
He was bleeding from a cut on his forehead.
Struggling against the officers holding him.
“Tell them, Sarah!” he begged. “Please!”
I leaned in close.
“You should have let him shoot me,” I whispered. “At least then you’d have had an alibi for the murder. Now you’re going down for everything. Fraud. Bigamy. Conspiracy. Attempted murder. You’re never getting out of prison, Daniel. Never.”
His face crumpled.
The officers led him away.
Maya came over.
“Nice work,” she said.
“He tried to have me killed,” I said. My voice sounded distant. “He actually stood there and let that man point a gun at me.”
“Technically, he lunged at the end.”
“Too little, too late.”
An officer came over.
“Mrs. Carter? We’re going to need a statement. And that bag in your trunk. We’ll need it as evidence.”
“Of course,” I said.
I looked around the parking lot.
Police cars everywhere.
Lights flashing.
People taking videos on their phones.
This was going to be all over the news by tonight.
And I was right in the middle of it.
My father pulled up beside me.
Rolled down his window.
“Get in,” he said. “I’ll take you home. The police can get your statement there. You’ve had enough excitement for one day.”
I got in the car.
As we pulled out of the parking lot, I looked back.
Daniel was sitting in the back of a police car.
Staring at me through the window.
Mouth moving.
Saying something I couldn’t hear.
But I knew what it was.
He was saying he was sorry.
He was saying he loved me.
He was saying anything he thought might save him.
None of it was true.
May you like
None of it had ever been true.
And for the first time since the night before, I let myself cry.