Chapter 4

Martin Cole's office was above a pizza place on the wrong side of town.
The stairs smelled like burnt cheese and regret. But when they walked through the door, the office itself was clean. Organized. Bookshelves lined with law books that actually looked used.
Cole himself was in his late fifties. Gray hair cut short. Wearing a shirt with no tie and sleeves rolled up. He had the kind of face that had seen every trick in the book and was still unimpressed.
“Abigail,” he said, standing and shaking her hand. “Naomi has told me the basics. Sit down. Tell me everything. From the beginning.”
So she did.
She told him about the first symptom last October. The trips to the ER in the middle of the night. The specialists in the city. The medications that cost more than her mortgage. The jewelry. The sewing machine. The twelve thousand from her brother.
She told him about the lottery ticket. About standing outside Room 12. About Spencer's voice on the speakerphone.
Cole said nothing while she spoke. He just took notes. Fast. In a notebook with a worn cover.
When she finished, he leaned back in his chair.
“Let me guess,” he said. “You've never actually seen any of the test results. You just take their word for it.”
Abigail's face burned.
“Spencer said the reports were too upsetting. That he didn't want me to worry more than I already was. He said—”
“He said exactly what every con artist says. 'I'm protecting you.' Which means 'I'm hiding the evidence.'”
Cole opened the envelope Naomi had brought. Spread the papers across his desk.
“Here's what we have. Dr. Marcus Henderson. License number 44729. Ten years ago, he lost his privileges at two hospitals for overprescribing opioids. Five years ago, he was investigated for insurance fraud. Case was dropped when the witness disappeared.”
He tapped a photograph.
“Spencer at the Sand Dollar Bar. April fourteenth. That's three days after he was admitted for 'acute gastrointestinal bleeding.' In this picture, he's doing shots. Standing up. No IV. No hospital bracelet visible.”
Another photograph.
“Spencer at the beach. May second. Two days after you took a second mortgage on the house to pay for an 'experimental treatment' in Mexico. Funny thing—there's no record of him ever leaving the country.”
Abigail felt the room closing in.
“The Mexico treatment. I wired seventy-five thousand dollars to a clinic in Tijuana.”
“Let me guess,” Cole said. “Spencer insisted on handling the transfer himself. Said the clinic only worked through a special account.”
“Yes.”
“That account was closed two days after the money arrived. It was never a clinic. It was a shell company. Probably set up by Henderson or whoever else is in on this.”
Seventy-five thousand dollars.
Every bit of equity she had built in thirty years of marriage. Gone. To a beach trip.
“Who else knows?” she asked. “His girlfriend, maybe? The woman he was talking to on the phone.”
“Brenda,” Naomi said. “Brenda Marlow. She's a nurse at the hospital. Not on your son's floor, but she has access. She's the one who helps him fake the symptoms. Administers the saline IVs that make him look pale and puffy. Switches his urine samples with real patients so the tests show abnormalities.”
Abigail closed her eyes.
She remembered Brenda. Met her twice at the hospital. Young. Pretty. Always so kind. Always telling Abigail what a strong woman she was, what a lucky son Spencer was to have her.
While they were both robbing her blind.
“Three people,” Cole said. “Spencer. Henderson. Brenda. Possibly more. This is organized. This isn't a kid scamming his mom for beer money. This is professional.”
He slid a document across the desk.
“Here's what we're going to do. First, you do NOT collect that lottery ticket yet. If Spencer sees you driving a new car or paying off bills, he'll know. He'll accelerate the scam. He might even try to get power of attorney or have you declared incompetent. These people have already proven they'll do anything.”
Abigail swallowed hard.
“Incompetent?”
“It happens. Sad son convinces a judge his grieving, overworked, exhausted mother can't handle her own finances. Suddenly he controls everything. You get an allowance. He gets twenty million dollars. And you spend your golden years in a one-bedroom apartment wondering what happened.”
The thought made her physically ill.
“Second,” Cole continued, “you go back to the hospital tomorrow. You act exactly like the mother you were yesterday. Devastated. Desperate. Willing to do anything. You tell Spencer the good news was that your brother agreed to lend you more money. Nothing about the lottery. Nothing about what you heard.”
“I don't know if I can do that,” Abigail said honestly. “Look him in the eye and pretend—”
“You have to,” Naomi said softly. “Because if he suspects you know, he disappears. He'll leave the state. Maybe the country. You'll never get your money back. And he'll do this to someone else's mother. Someone else's aunt. Someone else who loves too much.”
Abigail looked from one to the other.
The lawyer who had seen it all. The stranger who had lost her aunt to the same monster.
And outside, somewhere in the dark, her son was lying in a hospital bed planning his next move.
“What's the third step?” she asked.
Cole smiled. It was not a nice smile.
“Third, we let them dig their own grave. You keep giving them small amounts of money. Enough to keep them interested. Enough to make them believe the big score is still coming. And while they're busy performing for you, we build a case. Airtight. Every transaction. Every lie. Every fake test result. We record every conversation. We get every witness. And when the time is right—when they're so deep they can't climb out—we drop the hammer.”
He stood. The meeting was over.
“One more thing. Go home tonight. Check every document in your house. Bank statements. Insurance policies. The deed to your home. I need to know if they've already forged your signature on anything. Because if they have, this gets a whole lot worse before it gets better.”
Abigail drove home in a daze.
The house was exactly as she had left it. Quiet. Ordinary. Full of thirty-four years of memories that now felt like stolen property.
She went straight to the filing cabinet in the basement.
Pulled out the folder marked “House.”
And there it was.
A quitclaim deed. Dated three months ago. Transferring fifty percent ownership of her home to Spencer Riley.
May you like
Her signature was at the bottom.
She had never seen the document before in her life.