Chapter 4

Claire didn’t sleep that night.
She lay in the bed she’d shared with Ethan, the sheets still smelling like him, and stared at the ceiling. Every creak of the old building made her jump. Every car that passed on the street below sounded like Margaret coming back with more relatives, more police, more lies.
She got up at dawn. Made coffee. Sat at the kitchen table and stared at Lila’s text until the screen went dark.
At 9:30, she got dressed. Jeans. A plain white t-shirt. Ethan’s old leather jacket, the one that was too big for her but made her feel safe. She slipped the USB drive into the inner pocket, then grabbed her purse and left.
The coffee shop on Newbury was busy. Tourists with shopping bags. Students with laptops. The smell of espresso and cinnamon filled the air. Claire found a table in the back corner, where she could see the door, and ordered a black coffee.
She was stirring it when a woman slid into the seat across from her.
She was in her late twenties, with Ethan’s same dark hair and sharp, intelligent eyes. She had a scar on her left eyebrow, a small silver hoop in her nose, and a leather jacket that looked almost exactly like Claire’s. She smiled, and for a second Claire could see Ethan’s face in hers so clearly it made her chest ache.
“Lila?”
The woman nodded. She held out a hand. Her grip was firm.
“Claire. It’s good to finally meet you. Ethan talked about you all the time. Said you were the toughest person he ever knew.”
Claire’s throat tightened. “He talked about you too. In the letter he left me.”
Lila’s smile softened. She signaled the waitress and ordered a coffee, black, no sugar. Exactly like Ethan drank it.
“I was sorry I couldn’t make the funeral,” she said. “Margaret would have made a scene. Told everyone I was a gold digger too. I didn’t want to make things harder for you.”
Claire leaned forward. “How much do you know about what’s going on?”
“Everything,” Lila said. “Margaret called me yesterday. Bragged about how she was going to kick you out of the condo, take all the money, leave you with nothing. She asked me to help. Said she’d give me a cut if I testified that Ethan was crazy when he signed the will.”
Claire’s eyes widened. “What did you say?”
“I told her to go to hell.” Lila laughed, a dry, sharp sound. “I’ve spent my whole life watching that woman take things from people. From my mom. From your husband. From me. I’m not helping her do it again.”
She pulled a manila envelope from her bag and slid it across the table.
“Here’s what I’ve got. Emails between Margaret and her lawyer, dated three months before Ethan died. They were already planning to contest the will. Already talking about how to paint you as a gold digger, how to say you abused him, how to get the courts to side with her as the grieving mother. She had it all mapped out before he was even in the ground.”
Claire stared at the envelope. Her hands shook as she opened it. She pulled out the emails. Printed out, highlighted in yellow. There were dozens of them. Back and forth. Plans. Strategies. Lies they were going to tell.
One, dated two weeks before Ethan died, made her blood run cold.
If we can get the nurses to say she was neglecting him, we win. Pay them whatever it takes. No price is too high to get my son’s money back from that whore.
Claire looked up. “She was going to pay the nurses to lie?”
“Yep,” Lila said. “She tried. Two of them told me. They turned her down. Said Ethan loved you, said you were the best thing that ever happened to him. But she didn’t stop there. She’s got a PI digging into your past right now. Looking for anything. Old boyfriends. College mistakes. Anything she can use to ruin your name.”
Claire’s stomach turned. She’d made mistakes. Everyone had. When she was nineteen, she’d been arrested at a protest against tuition hikes. The charges had been dropped, expunged from her record. But if Margaret found out… she’d twist it. Make her sound like a criminal. Like a violent thug who’d married Ethan to steal his money.
“What do you want?” Claire asked.
Lila leaned back. She looked Claire straight in the eye.
“Ten percent of the trust.”
Claire froze. “Excuse me?”
“Ten percent,” Lila repeated. “That’s 240 thousand. For all of this. The emails. The proof she tried to pay off the nurses. Everything else I’ve got on her. I’ll testify for you. I’ll stand up in court and tell everyone who she really is. I’ll help you bury her. But I get paid.”
Claire stared at her. “Ethan said you were good people.”
“I am good people,” Lila said. “But good people don’t work for free. I grew up poor. My mom worked three jobs to raise me. We ate government cheese for dinner half the time. Margaret had all the money, all the privilege, and she let us rot. I’m not asking for more than I’m worth. Ten percent is nothing compared to what you get to keep. And without me, you’re fighting her alone. You think you can win? She’s got money. She’s got friends. She’s been lying and manipulating people for fifty years. You’re just a waitress who got lucky.”
The words stung. Same ones Margaret had used. But there was truth in them too. Claire was out of her depth. She didn’t know how to fight someone like Margaret. Someone who had no shame, no limits, no conscience.
“Let me think about it,” Claire said.
Lila stood up. She threw a ten dollar bill on the table for the coffee.
“You have 48 hours. After that, I sell what I’ve got to Margaret. She’ll pay me twice as much to testify against you. Don’t make me do that. I don’t want to be on her side. But I’ve got bills to pay. And I’m done being the secret Walker who gets nothing.”
She walked out.
Claire sat there for a long time, staring at the emails in front of her. Ten percent was a lot of money. But if Lila was telling the truth, it was worth every penny.
She called Marcus. Told him about the meeting. About Lila’s offer.
“Don’t do it,” Marcus said immediately. “She’s playing you. If she had real proof, she’d give it to you out of loyalty to Ethan. She’s just another grifter, same as the rest of them. We don’t need her. We’ve got the will. We’ve got the video. We’ll win in court.”
“What if she sells to Margaret?” Claire asked. “What if she testifies that Ethan was incompetent? She’s his sister. A jury might believe her.”
There was a pause on the line.
“Then we fight harder. But you don’t negotiate with people like her. It never ends. She’ll come back for more. Twenty percent. Thirty. You’ll be paying her forever.”
Claire hung up. She sat there, torn. Marcus was probably right. But what if he was wrong? What if Lila was the only one who could take Margaret down for good?
She walked home. Her head was spinning. When she turned onto her street, she saw a group of people standing on the sidewalk in front of her building. They were holding signs.
GOLD DIGGER CLAIRE.
ETHAN DESERVED BETTER.
MURDERER.
Claire stopped cold. Her blood ran cold.
Margaret was standing in the middle of them, talking to a woman with a camera. A reporter from the local news. She was crying, dabbing her eyes with a tissue, pointing up at Claire’s condo.
“She killed him,” Margaret was saying, loud enough for everyone to hear. “Slowly. For his money. And now she’s hiding in there, counting my son’s cash, while he’s cold in the ground.”
The reporter turned and saw Claire. She started walking toward her, microphone out. The protestors turned too. They started shouting.
Murderer. Thief. Gold digger.
Claire turned and ran.
She didn’t stop until she was three blocks away, hiding in an alley, her chest heaving. She pulled out her phone. Scrolled through Facebook. Her feed was full of it. Posts from Margaret. Posts from the relatives. Posts from people she’d never met, calling her every name in the book.
A comment from someone she’d gone to high school with popped up.
I always knew she was trash. Married him for his money the second she found out he was sick.
Claire dropped her phone. It clattered on the pavement. She slid down the brick wall of the alley, sat on the dirty ground, and cried.
Marcus was wrong. She couldn’t win this with just the will and the video. Margaret was playing dirty. She was destroying Claire’s name, one lie at a time, and soon everyone would believe her.
Claire pulled out her phone again. Wiped the tears from her eyes. Found Lila’s number.
May you like
Typed a single text.
You’ve got a deal.