Chapter 4

I hired a private investigator the next day. A man named Tom, quiet and sharp, who’d spent twenty years on the police force.
“I need everything,” I told him. “Every text, every call, every witness who saw her hurt Maya. I need proof that will hold up in court.”
Tom nodded. “I’ll get it. But you should know—stepchild abuse cases are hard. She’s going to say Maya is lying, that you’re coaching her. We need ironclad evidence.”
I also hired a lawyer, Clara Bennett, who specialized in family law and child abuse cases. She was tough, no-nonsense, with a scar across her left cheek and a look in her eye that said she didn’t lose.
“Eleanor is going to play dirty,” she warned me at our first meeting. “She’ll try to paint you as an absent father, as someone who’s using his daughter to get out of paying alimony. We need to be ready for anything.”
I spent every free minute with Maya. We fixed her stuffed rabbit together, we bought new crayons and coloring books, we baked cookies that burned to a crisp but she ate them anyway. She still flinched when I moved too fast, still woke up screaming from nightmares, still wouldn’t eat at the dining room table. She preferred to sit on the kitchen floor next to me while I cooked.
One night, as I was tucking her into her new bed—we’d bought a real one, with pink sheets and a canopy—she grabbed my hand.
“Daddy?”
“Yeah, baby?”
“Is Eleanor ever going to come back?”
I squeezed her hand. “No. She’s never going to hurt you again.”
She was quiet for a minute. “What if she lies? What if everyone believes her instead of you?”
I sat down on the edge of the bed. “No one is going to believe her. Because the truth is on our side. And I will never, ever let anyone take you away from me.”
She nodded, but her eyes were still scared.
Two weeks later, Tom called me. His voice was tight.
“I got the security footage,” he said.
I drove to his office immediately, my hands shaking. He pulled up a video on his computer.
The timestamp was three weeks earlier, a day I’d been in New York for a meeting.
The kitchen. Eleanor was standing by the counter, a glass of wine in her hand. Maya walked in, holding her stomach.
“I’m hungry,” she said quietly.
Eleanor turned to her, her face cold. “I told you, you don’t eat until I say you can. You were bad today. You talked back to me.”
Maya’s lip trembled. “Please. I didn’t mean to.”
Eleanor slammed her wine glass down on the counter so hard the liquid sloshed over the edge. “Get out of my kitchen. Go to the pantry. And don’t come out until I tell you to.”
Maya turned and ran, her shoulders shaking.
The next clip was from two days later. Maya was in the hallway, holding a drawing she’d made. Eleanor walked past, grabbed the drawing, and ripped it in half.
“Ugly,” she said, dropping the pieces on the floor. “Just like you.”
I felt sick. I watched ten more clips, each one worse than the last. Eleanor yelling at Maya, calling her names, pushing her into a wall when she tried to hug her. Locking her in the pantry for hours at a time.
Tom turned off the video. “I also talked to the housekeeper. Maria. She said she tried to stop Eleanor once, and Eleanor threatened to fire her and have her deported. She’s willing to testify, if we can get her immunity and a new job.”
“Give her whatever she needs,” I said, my voice rough. “All of them. Anyone who saw what happened.”
Clara called me an hour later. “Eleanor just filed a countersuit. She’s claiming you emotionally abused her, that you’re an unfit father, and that you’ve been coaching Maya to lie about her. She’s asking for full custody of Maya and fifty percent of your assets.”
I closed my eyes, my head throbbing.
I’d known it was coming. But it still felt like a punch to the gut.
May you like
“Let her try,” I said. “We have the footage. We have witnesses. We’re going to win.”
“I hope so,” Clara said quietly. “Because if we don’t, she could take Maya away from you forever.”